J.D. Lafrance
Platoon: 20th Anniversary Edition DVD Review

Platoon: 20th Anniversary Edition

May 30, 2006

Director: Oliver Stone,
Starring: Charlie Sheen, Tom Berenger, Willem Dafoe, Forest Whitaker, John C. McGinley, Kevin Dillon, Keith David, Johnny Depp, Mark Moses, Richard Edson, Francesco Quinn, David Neidorf,

Rate Platoon: 20th Anniversary Edition DVD Release:
1 Star2 Stars3 Stars4 Stars5 Stars (No Ratings Yet)

DVD Review

J.D. Lafrance

While Platoon (1986) was certainly not the first film about the Vietnam War, it was one of the first to focus on the average foot soldier in an honest and authentic way. Oliver Stone’s film really put you in the jungle with these guys as only someone who was there could. The film has already been released twice on DVD and this new edition celebrates its 20th anniversary with several new extras but is the third time really the charm?

Platoon focuses on the 25th Infantry, Bravo Company in September 1967 with new recruit Chris Taylor (Sheen) as the audience surrogate and our introduction to this world. We see the war through his eyes, from that first blast of bright light as he walks off the plane with other newbies and they see a collection of body bags. They are then taunted by a group of battle-hardened veterans heading home. That will be them some day…if they live long enough.

Stone quickly cuts to the jungle and immerses us in it – dense foliage that makes it hard to see more than a few feet in front of you, the sounds of birds and other exotic animals and the oppressive heat that you can see on the sweaty, tired faces of the soldiers. This is not easy terrain to navigate and Stone makes sure we know it. He shows just how hard it is to fight in the jungle with a night time ambush that goes bad. Everything happens so fast and so chaotic that it is hard to follow what is going on until it’s all over.

The film sets up a platoon divided into two factions: the dope smoking guys who just want to survive the war and go home and the beer-drinking lifers who actually like it there or, at the very least, believe that what they are doing is right. The leaders of these two groups, Sergeant Elias (Dafoe) and Sergeant Barnes (Berenger), are polar opposites that Chris gravitates towards and must ultimately choose between.

At that point in his career, Willem Dafoe was known for playing bad guy roles in films like Streets of Fire (1984) and To Live and Die in L.A. (1985) and so casting him as a good guy in Platoon must’ve seemed like a gamble. Dafoe is excellent as a dedicated soldier who takes the time to teach Chris a few things in order for him to survive. It’s a very soulful performance as he acts as the platoon’s conscience. Elias cares about his men and wants to see them all go home alive.

In contrast, Tom Berenger had been known for playing lightweight, good guy roles but caught Stone’s eye with his layered performance in The Big Chill (1983). He gives an absolutely ferocious performance as an intense, imposing figure who rules his men with an iron fist. He’s a tough man who leads by example, strict and unwavering in his beliefs. Berenger hadn’t really done anything before this to suggest such intensity and his performance was a revelation and still his best to date.

Platoon packs in a lot of stuff: botched ambushes, the destruction of a village, discovery of an underground bunker and a climatic, large scale battle that probably wouldn’t have all gone down in such a limited time frame but Stone isn’t interested in making a documentary. His is a dramatization of a composite of several events that gives the audience some idea of what it was like there and what these guys went through.

The film’s centerpiece features the frustrated and edgy platoon taking out their anger on a village by raping their women, killing their livestock and even some the inhabitants. It is at this point when the conflict between the two sides of the platoon boils over. It is a gut-wrenching sequence, even after all these years, full of anger and madness. Stone underscores what an impossible situation the war was and one, now in retrospect, that the United States had no chance of winning because they were so out of their depth. Platoon is even more poignant now that we are embroiled in another Vietnam of sorts over in Iraq with U.S. soldiers dying almost every day for what many argue are for all the wrong reasons. It makes Stone’s film even more relevant today than it was 20 years ago.

Special Features:

The last Platoon DVD had some impressive extras, most notably two audio commentaries and a retrospective making of documentary. These have been included along with several additional featurettes and deleted scenes.

The first disc features an audio commentary by Oliver Stone. He gives his personal reflections of his experiences in Vietnam and points out the autobiographical elements in the movie, like how early on in his tour he was put on point just like Chris was in the movie. Stone also talks about the challenges of making Platoon on a low budget and working in a harsh, unforgiving environment. This track is filled with fascinating personal insights and is essential listening for any fan of the movie.

Also included is a commentary track by the film’s military advisor Dale Dye, a retired Marine of 22 years with 30 months in Vietnam. He points out that the actors had been training hard for 14 days when the opening credits sequence was shot and were very tired making their reactions very real. Dye made sure that every actor had their own distinctive look and points out the authenticity of the uniforms. Best of all, he points out all the little details that made Platoon so true to what it must’ve been like there, things that veterans of the war would recognize instantly. This is a great track that is technical but also accessible and really makes you appreciate the amount of work that went into this movie.

All of the new extras are contained on the second disc, starting with “Deleted and Extended Scenes” with optional commentary by Stone. Included is the first time Chris smokes pot; a speech about love and hate that pays homage to Night of the Hunter (1955) and that also gives Johnny Depp’s character more screen time; and some good exchanges between characters. Most interestingly, is an alternate ending for Barnes which Stone says he now wishes had been used.

“Snapshot in Time: 1967-1968” gives a historical perspective to the time period the film takes place in and puts things into perspective by exploring the origins of the conflict and how the U.S. got involved.

“Creating the ‘Nam” takes a look at how the filmmakers created the condition of Vietnam in the Philippines on a limited budget. It also examines the grueling shoot that drove Stone to exhaustion. Some highlights include a bit about how they created the village in the movie from scratch and did such a good job that locals moved in with no prompting!

“Raw Wounds: The Legacy of Platoon” examines the film’s legacy and how it gave veterans the dignity they deserved and allowed the U.S. to come to terms with the war. However, some veterans were upset at how they were portrayed in the film and were worried that people would come away from it thinking that they just smoked dope and tried to kill each other or innocent civilians.

“One War, Many Stories” features a group of vets talking about the movie after a screening and how it relates to their own experiences. These guys tell some fascinating stories that are in turn juxtaposed with Stone talking about his own experiences. Some of these men’s stories are quite moving as they are still quite affected by what they went through.

Included from the previous edition is “Tour of the Inferno,” an excellent, in-depth retrospective documentary that brought back a lot of the film’s cast who talk about their experiences making the film. We are taken through the various stages of production with some great anecdotes being told of the wild times these guys had, including John C. McGinley doing a funny as hell impersonation of Stone and Berenger telling a story about the real Barnes that was used in the movie. This is a fantastic doc that manages not to repeat too much of what was said in the two commentary tracks.

“Preparing for the ‘Nam” exam

J.D. is a freelance writer who is currently doing research for a book on the films of Michael Mann. He likes reading anything written by Jack Kerouac, James Ellroy, J.D. Salinger, Harlan Ellison or Thomas Pynchon. J.D. is currently addicted to the T.V. series 24 and enjoys drinking a lot of Sprite. This is not a blatant plug for the beverage but if they ever decided to give him a lifetime supply he certainly wouldn’t turn them down.
view all DVD reviews by JD Lafrance


Rating: 99%



Got something to say?